spacepace  

PUBLIC ACCOUNTING PRACTICE AND EDUCATION IN THE UNITED STATES THROUGH 1906

     New York City served as the first home for accounting in the United States. It was here, in the early decades of the 19th century, that sole practitioners began to offer accounting services to the public, and that the nation’s first self-styled accounting school taught bookkeeping and mathematical science for a brief time beginning in 1818.

     Public accountants appeared in greater numbers during the 1850’s in both New York City and Philadelphia. By the 1880’s their work had become increasingly professional in nature by providing more than the routine accounting functions. There were 155 public accountants in New York City in 1886 and accounting firms in partnership form existed there from as early as 1866. Philadelphia’s Wharton School of Business was established in 1881, and began to teach accounting in 1883.

     During the last quarter of the nineteenth century business and industry flourished throughout the nation, with New York City as the principal commercial center. Industrial concerns incorporated and their securities were publicly sold; there were financial panics in 1873 and 1893; monopolies were created; labor unions emerged and strikes took place; Congress enacted an Interstate Commerce Act and the Sherman Antitrust Act to regulate business.

     As business organizations and regulation grew so did the larger New York public accounting firms. At first there were imports from England, namely Barrow, Wade, Guthrie + Co. in 1883, and Jones, Caeser + Co (now Price Waterhouse and Co.) in 1890, but then American firms were founded – Haskins & Sells (now Deloitte & Touche) in 1895, and Lybrand, Ross Bros. & Montgomery (now Coopers and Lybrand) in 1898. Large organizations prominently U. S. Steel in 1891, engaged the larger CPA firms to audit their records. In 1902 U.S. Steel began the practice of having auditors elected by stockholders and publicly issuing an audit certificate signed by the CPA firm.

     The first U. S. accounting organization was the Institute of Accountants and Bookkeepers formed in New York City in 1882 and later known as the Institute of Accountants. Many of its members engaged in public practice and one class of them needed to pass difficult exams. It focused upon pioneering accounting education and providing accounting literature.

 

       In 1887 the first national organization of public accountants was incorporated as the American Association of Public Accountants. Today its name is the American Institute of Certified Public Accountants. It had been founded at 45 William Street in downtown Manhattan and most of its early members practiced in New York City. In 1892 it was granted a provisional charter by the New York State Board of Regents to start a college for accountants; however, the school was not successful.

     CPA exams were first given in December 1896 when New York State gave the profession of independent certified public accountants its first legal recognition. An exam candidate had to be at least 25 years old with 3 years experience, at least one of them in a public accounting office. The initial exam and its early successors dealt largely with today’s basics but reflected public accounting practice of that era.

     Two years and two exams went by before six CPA certificates were finally issued as a result of the third exam in 1898. By 1906, after 10 New York State exams, only 188 certificates had been granted based upon examinations although 185 were granted based upon waiver of the exam for persons who had practiced public accounting for at least one year before the passage of the 1896 CPA law. Throughout the United States only 617 certificates had been issued by 1906, half of them in New York.

     During the first decade of the twentieth century the CPA profession grew rapidly in prestige and an increasing number of larger corporations chose to retain CPAs to perform periodic audits. The need for properly educated accountants was growing much more quickly than the supply.

     In 1900 only 12 colleges and universities offered accounting courses, and only 4 of them included auditing courses. New York University started classes in the first department of accounting in 1901. In 1902, evening classes sponsored by the Pennsylvania Institute of Public Accountants began to prepare students for the CPA exam. Those classes were turned over to Wharton in 1904. Accounting literature was almost nonexistent at the time.

     This was the educational and professional environment in public accounting when the Pace brothers embarked upon their educational venture in 1906.

By Allan M. Rabinowitz